Open Source ERP or Managed Services? Finding the right solution for your business needs

Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) software is an essential component for any businesses, irrespective of the size or industry. An ERP solution enables a business to automate, integrate, and streamline business processes, thereby making operations more efficient. A business may choose to implement either an Open Source ERP or go with a managed services provider, depending on the resources that are at their disposal.

Below is a brief comparison showing the pros and cons of the two options.

The Pros of Open Source ERP vs. Managed ERP Services

Accessibility:

Open Source ERP software is easily accessible, since you can download from the internet, at no cost. For this reason, even the small and medium sized business that had no access previously, have a chance to try out ERP software.
open source erp vs. managed provider
Commercial ERP software must be purchased from the vendor. The vendor will then issue licenses and terms for its use, normally forbidding any form of distribution. For this reason, the software is only made available to those companies that are able to pay, in order to use it.

Cost:

Open source ERP software is available online, free of charge. Therefore, no acquisition, implementation, or licensing costs are necessary. In addition, the developers or third parties make every effort to have documentation and training tutorials, which users can download and use for implementing the system, as well as training their employees. However, third parties may charge a small fee, in order to access their documentation and tutorials.

On the other hand, managed ERP services are quite costly, thus making them out of reach for most small and medium-sized enterprises. Some of these costs include the software acquisition costs, licensing costs, employee training costs, and professional fees.

Scalability:

Open Source ERP is scalable. For this reason, the solution caters for the needs of both small and medium businesses, as well as large enterprises.

Commercial ERP solutions, on the other hand, are designed with the large businesses in mind. Therefore, they will tend to be more complex and have features that cannot be implemented or be applicable for the small business.

Flexibility:

With Open Source software, everyone has access to the source code. In addition, anyone has the right to modify or tamper with the code, provided it is done in accordance with the software agreement. As such, a business has the opportunity to implement some features, or customize the system to meet individual needs of the business.

Commercial ERP software does not allow for any modifications. The license agreement strictly prohibits tampering with the code, and gives all the rights to the respective vendors. Therefore, the vendor must be contacted to undertake any modifications that may be required.

The Cons of Open Source ERP vs. Managed ERP Services

Support:

The greatest disadvantage of using Open Source ERP is the fact that the business has to independently, manage its ERP system. Therefore, no technical or professional support is available. As such, a business is forced to manage, backup, and even troubleshoot their system. In extreme cases, a business might need to hire the services of a competent professional to manage the system internally.

With managed services, the business gets to enjoy various additional services from the vendor. These services may include hosting, backup and recovery, troubleshooting, and regular updates.

Features:

In as much as the developers of Open Source ERP will make every effort to include all the major features that are found in the commercial ERP systems, it is common to find some important features missing. Usually, Open Source software is developed, as a result team effort, relying on the input of volunteers with specialized skill in the various areas involved. Therefore, lack of such skilled personnel results in certain features being left out. Apart from this, the funds that are required to develop and test some the features may lack.

On the other hand, companies that have sufficient resources, in terms of funds and skilled manpower, develop the commercially managed systems. This ensures that all the required features are included.

Overall, the Open Source ERP system has its advantages and disadvantages over the managed service. However, the fact that the commercial solution is out of reach for many small and medium-sized businesses makes the Open Source ERP a viable solution to streamline their business processes.

 

How to determine your ERP Evaluation Criteria

Defining your ERP Evaluation Criteria is essential for paring down the vendors and getting to the final choice.  There are two focus areas for determining your selection criteria:

ERP Evaluation Criteria

Determining your ERP Evaluation Criteria

1. ERP Evaluation Criteria – Process

The Process analysis for determining your ERP Evaluation Criteria is the method you would use to determine the flow of data through the system and how it would follow along your established or to-be business processes.  For example, following a process flow of quoting an order, receiving the order, manufacturing or purchasing the product, shipping, and finally invoicing the order is known as the order-to-cash process flow.

There are other anther ERP Evaluation Criteria processes such as procure-to-pay, which maps the inventory requirement through the accounts payable billings. Another example could be the HR process of recruiting though retirement.

ERP Evaluation Criteria

Using Process Flow documentation to determine your ERP Evaluation Criteria

By mapping out these processes in a tool such as Microsoft Visio Standard 2010ERP Evaluation Criteria and developing a detailed flow diagram, you will have a good understanding of how your business operates.  With this knowledge, your evaluation of various business management software will be a lot easier.  Further, you can see how closely the software’s process flow mirrors your company’s or how disjointed the software is when it comes to your business.

2. ERP Evaluation Criteria – Functional

ERP Evaluation Criteria for the system is the detailed list of all of the things you need the system to do, from processing purchase orders, processing a sales order, to invoicing a client and producing financial reports.  These are the nitty gritty things that your system should do.  A good place to start is to evaluate your current system.  What are the functions that the current system does well?  Include these in your list.  What are the things that your system does poorly, include the desired functionality in your list.

Your list should not be 10,000 lines, but rather it should look at those items that make your business unique.  For example, most every business has to cut A/P checks.  So most systems can do that.  So do not list as a requirement that the software should be able to cut A/P checks, rather make your requirement specific to your company, such as “System should be able to cut 3 copy laser checks, with reprint capability.”  That very specific requirement will help you distinguish the vendors from one another.

A good place to start is with an ERP Evaluation Criteria Template.  ERPandMore has many different templates to assist you in evaluating various ERP software venders and have best practices built in.  In using these as a starting point, you will save yourself countless hours in both preparing these criteria templates as well as in differentiating the vendors your are looking at. We hope this has helped to answer How to determine your ERP Evaluation Criteria

When to use ERP Software Consultants

When to use ERP Software Consultants

Many times companies try to select and implement ERP software on their own. Sometimes this works and sometimes it doesn’t. So the question is, when should a company use an ERP Software Consultant to guide them in their ERP Selection or ERP Implementation?

The answer is not so simple. If a company is mature and has the resources that can look independently at the business processes, then it may make sense to embark on a selection on their own. Most of the time in mid-market sized or even smaller clients, then it is difficult for them to 1. Spare the resources and 2. Look at the business processes objectively.

Any good ERP Selection begins with a company evaluating their business processes. Borrowing from the Toyota Production system (aka Lean Manufacturing), a company should first eliminate waste and then consider automating. Automating bad processes will only make things worse faster. However, automating good processes will help grow the business and promote better communication.

ERP Software Consultants
Image via Wikipedia

ERP Software Consultants – Best Practices

The real question becomes how much is the company willing to flex their processes to adapt to “best practices” that are usually built into a commercial software system. If the company is flexible (and this takes a lot of leadership to make happen), they can select a system and model their business around that system. The larger commercial systems, such as those from Microsoft, Infor, SAP, Oracle, and others have all grown up from thousands of implementations from all sorts of companies. They have developed efficiencies that many companies who adopt the software’s methodology can benefit from.

The real key is understanding the fit of a software package to the business. If the company does some niche processing, then a mainstream commercial package may not fit. However it the company is a distributor or a manufacturer of discrete products as an example, then a standard mid-market product would likely work for them.

So how do you choose the software, it is back to the business processes and the key requirements. “Key Requirements,” not just all requirements. The things that the old system does not do well and those things that it does very well are good places to start. Additionally, discover those requirements or processes that set your company apart from others in your industry. Usually processes around your competitive advantage are part of the key requirements.

Going back to the original question, should you use independent ERP Software Consultants? If you have a clear and objective understanding, you can afford the time to really research the vendors and you have a strong will with salespeople, then going it on your own might be reasonable.

If you do not have the time, the understanding of the ERP Software market, or the will power to manage at an arm’s length the software vendor’s salespeople, then an ERP Software Consultant would be a wise choice.

ERP Vendor Selection
ERP Software Consultants
Enhanced by Zemanta

ERP Software Solution: A Closer Look at What It Is

ERP Software Solution: A Closer Look at What It Is
Mike Piotrowski
ERP Solution

Information technology has not only transformed the way we live in modern society, but also the way in which we do business. Enterprise Resource Planning, often referred to as ERP, is becoming one of the most commonly used software systems in several industries and organizations. The object of this article is to provide pertinent highlights about exactly what ERP is.

The definition of Enterprise Resource Planning refers to not only software but also the business strategies employed as part of the implementation of ERP systems. This implementation makes use of various software applications in order to improve the performances of organizations in resource planning, control of operations, and control of management.

ERP software contains several software modules that work to integrate vital activities across operating departments. An ERP System not only includes the ERP Software but also the business processes and hardware that make this system work. These systems are more than the sums of their parts as the many components work together in order to achieve one common objective-to provide an organization with a greatly improved and streamlined business process.

History of ERP

ERP has been well over 20 years in the making. This system is the result of the trial, error, and growth of Manufacturing Requirements Planning (MRP) during the 80’s. MRP was the evolution of Inventory Management and Control, which was conceived during the 1960’s. ERP has grown beyond the coordination of manufacturing processes into the integration of back end processing on very large scales. From its origins as a legacy implementation ERP has morphed into a new and improved client-server architecture.

Benefits of ERP

This software attempts to bring all aspects of the business into one single enterprise-wide database or information system. This allows instantaneous information and communications to be shared between multiple departments. The primary benefit of this is a greatly improved efficiency in business operations. Implementing this system will not only help communications between departments but in day-to-day management functions as well. ERP is an ambitious design that also supports the resource planning part of corporate planning as this is often the weakest link in strategic planning as the result of the inadequate integration of ERP software with Decision Support Systems.

ERP Failures

It would be quite rude to conclude without at least mentioning the fact that failures in this system are occasionally reported in one of the four components of an ERP System. These systems are: ERP software, Business processes supported by the ERP System, Users of the ERP Systems, and the hardware and/or operating systems upon which the ERP applications are actually run. The failure of one or more of these components has the potential to cause the entire ERP project to fail.
Ontech Systems of Milwaukee Wisconsin, is committed to making a difference in your business through the productive use of computers, networks, software and the vast array of products and services we offer. Contact Mike Piotrowski, President of Ontech Systems to discuss a new ERP business solution for your company today.
Provided By: Computers and Technology

ERP Packages Feature Comparison

7 Ways to Fail in an ERP Selection

7 Ways to Fail in an ERP Selection

by Chris Shaul

The best way to fail at an Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) implementation is to choose the wrong software up front. Choosing software without following some basic guidelines is a sure-fire method for disaster. Probably the worst thing that someone has done (that we know of), was to buy their ERP software at a tradeshow, thinking it would be the cheap and easy way to solve their problems. They ended up spending more than they expected in finding ways to force the software into their business all because of a failed ERP selection.

Below are some ways that will set you on the path to fail at your choice. In other words, they are ways that you can insure that you will choose the wrong system for your company.

ERP Selection Failures

1. Choose ERP software without understanding your requirements. First, you should ensure that you are getting the best fit for your company by documenting your requirements. The requirements should cover the strategic, reporting, functional, and technical aspects of what your company requires to run the business. Choosing software without these documented and without using them as a benchmark to compare the software against is a strategy for problems. Do not run an ERP Selection without well defined requirements.

2. Select ERP software without paying attention to business processes. There are certain ways that you run your business. Not all of them are rocket science, but there are certain things that make your company unique and successful. Choosing software without understanding how things flow in your company will create big problems in the implementation when the software processes information contrary to how you run your business.

3. Choose ERP software because your Friend/Neighbor/Relative is using it successfully at their firm. Another nightmare scenario that has actually occurred is that decision makers have purchased software because their ____ (fill in the blank) has used it and it worked great at that company. That company is not your company. On the surface they may seem similar, but just because one company is running well on the ERP system does not mean that yours will. You may have a special process for getting your goods out the door. The software may not support that method. Perhaps there is some information that you must have because of financial, regulatory, or supply chain requirements. The other company may not have that issue. Perhaps you need to track lot numbers and the _____ ‘s company does not. There are too many business issues that can create havoc in an information system, if the system is not carefully matched to the requirements (see #1).

4. Not having the ERP vendor prove that it will support your business processes. ERP vendors have one goal. Sell you software. Do they care if it fits, can successfully operate your business, or even if it will be a huge burden on your staff? Not really. In fact, if you buy software that requires a lot of care and feeding because it is not a good fit, then the vendor is the one who supports it and makes a handsome flow of income off your company. You can find a software that best fits your business with a free ERP Selection consultation from SoftwareAdvice.com. Get the vendor to demonstrate that it meets your requirements and can transact information in a method that is aligned with your business processes.

5. Choosing ERP software because it looks cool. You may laugh at this one, but the user interface is a sexy selling point of many systems. Is a plain old green-screen as nice to work in as a really colorful Windows screen? Probably not, but does the Windows-based system really address your issues? Your goal should be aligning a perspective system with your business needs. If it comes with a cool interface great, if not, can you live with it?

6. Let the ERP vendor tell you what you need to be doing. Related to number 4 above, having the ERP vendor guide you in your selection is a roadmap to hell. You need to guide them. Tell them what you want and expect. Too many times has a single vendor gained the trust and confidence of a decision maker and guided them to a particular system, without any concern for how close a match is it to the business requirements and processes.

7. Take the ERP vendor’s first offer without negotiating. You can generally negotiate with a vendor several times and get a more than fair price. But the key is to follow good negotiation tactics. Don’t forget that most everything is negotiable. The software, the services, the maintenance, the timing, etc. In the ERP industry, the best time to do an ERP selection is at the quarter or year end according to the vendor’s financial calendar.

The key thing to understand is that there is a path that can lead you to success and many routes to failure. Know thyself first. Understand your business and document it. It is not enough to think you know it. Talk to all levels of users and managers. Ensure that everyone’s needs are defined and a priority is placed upon those needs. If you are not sure of how to run an ERP Selection, then get outside help from a consultant who is non-biased towards systems and can guide you. Be careful of assistance from a company that has an SAP practice, or an Oracle practice, etc. They have internal motivation to help you choose their flavor of software.

Most importantly, understand that you need to drive the process. It is your selection and you need to live with the results. As any good project manager will tell you, start with the end in mind. What do you want the system to do for your company now and in seven years from now? Understand this and go forward in your ERP selection.


Chris Shaul is a Senior IT Consultant who is a regular contributor to ERPandMore.com

ERP Selection Help

ERP Selection

ERP is in the picture for midsize manufacturers

Small and midsize manufacturers are increasing IT investment because they don’t have the IT architecture needed to compete in a demand-driven world. For many, this means going back to the basics: an ERP system that standardizes business processes, extends the company’s reach, and reduces overhead.

In a 2005 study of more than 550 companies’ ERP investment plans, only 27 percent of small companies “those with fewer than 500 employees” currently …more… (requires registration)